Staten Island • Church, Synagogue, Chapel

1265 Castleton Ave

Staten Island, NY 10310Individually ownedBBL 5002030001BIN 5803594

Updated Aug 1, 2026 · 16 sources

Year Built1969
Floors2
Units1
Building Area14,791 sqft
ZoningC8-1
ClassM1
Market Value$4.4M

1265 CASTLETON AVE is a property located at 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310. It is classified as a church, synagogue, chapel. The building was constructed in 1969. It has 2 floors and 1 unit. The building area is 14,791 square feet on a 18,300 sqft lot. The property is zoned C8-1. The assessed market value is $4.4M. Public records list the property as individually owned. There are 8 building permits on record (5 active). There are 27 violations on record (16 currently open). Data sourced from NYC Department of Buildings (DOB), Housing Preservation & Development (HPD), Department of Finance (DOF), and other government agencies.

A RegWatch Dossier

74records on file
53Energy Star

Completed in 1969, 1265 Castleton Ave rises 2 stories over Richmond. Public records put it at 1 unit and 14,791 square feet of floor area, on land zoned C8-1. It is carried on the public rolls at a market value of $4.4M, and assessed for tax at $2.0M. In the 36 years its record reaches back, the lot has drawn 74 separate government filings.

The documentary life of the address leans hard toward violation: 27 of its 74 records, fully 36%, fall under that one heading. Inspection (18) and assignment (13) trail well behind. 16 violations stand open against it today.

The pace is anything but even. Activity is spread across the decades, with 1994 the busiest year on file.

On the environmental ledger, the building posts an Energy Star score of 53, with a site energy-use intensity of 38.5 kBtu per square foot. Its operations answer for roughly 75 metric tons of CO2-equivalent a year.

Read together — 36% violation, 36 years of accumulation, a parcel of Richmond — these scattered records compose a portrait of the address that no single page sets out to draw.

$4.4M of Richmond, written across 74 government filings.

Property Details

Address1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310
Building TypeChurch, Synagogue, Chapel
M1
Year Built1969
Floors2
Total Units1
Building Area14,791 sqft
Lot Size18,300 sqft
ZoningC8-1
5002030001
5803594 +1 more
OwnershipIndividually owned

Assessment & Sales

$4.4M
$2M
$206K

Building Permits

8 on record · 5 active
Alteration — Type 2DOB Legacy
SIGNED OFF
Filed Mar 2, 2016Est. cost $29KJob #520242256-01
Construction EquipmentDOB Legacy
ISSUED
Filed May 15, 2015Job #520242256-01-01
Alteration — Type 2DOB Legacy
SIGNED OFF
Filed Jul 20, 2011Est. cost $200KJob #520046913-01
Construction EquipmentDOB Legacy
ISSUED
Filed Sep 16, 2010Job #520046913-01-01
Construction EquipmentDOB Legacy
ISSUED
Filed Sep 16, 2010Job #520046913-1-1-hist

+ 3 more permitsview full report

Violations

27 on record · 16 open
DOB LegacyLocal Law 62/91
ACTIVE
Issued Sep 16, 1997#547960
DOB LegacyLocal Law 62/91
ACTIVE
Issued Sep 16, 1997#547961
DOB LegacyLocal Law 62/91
ACTIVE
Issued Jun 8, 1994#319398
DOB LegacyLocal Law 62/91
ACTIVE
Issued Jun 8, 1994#319399
DOB LegacyLocal Law 62/91
ACTIVE
Issued Jun 8, 1994#319400

+ 22 more violations on record — view full report

Get the Complete Report for 1265 CASTLETON AVE

Title history, detailed tax records, environmental data, zoning analysis, and more from 250+ government sources.

Free to view core records, no credit card required — the paid report adds title history & analysis.

View Report

Frequently Asked Questions

When was 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island built?

The building at 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310 was constructed in 1969. It is classified as a church, synagogue, chapel with 2 floors and 1 unit. The building area is 14,791 sqft.

Are there building permits at 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island?

Yes. 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310 has 8 building permits on record, with 5 currently active. Permits are sourced from the NYC Department of Buildings (DOB Legacy and DOB NOW systems). The most recent permit is a Alteration — Type 2 (SIGNED OFF) filed Mar 2, 2016.

Does 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island have violations?

Yes. 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310 has 27 violations on record, with 16 currently open. Breakdown: 26 DOB, 1 ECB. Sources: NYC DOB, HPD, and ECB/OATH.

Does 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island have docketed judgments?

No docketed OATH judgments were found in local records for 1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310. Judgment data is sourced from NYC Office of Administrative Trials & Hearings (OATH) hearing records.

What is the property tax assessment for 1265 CASTLETON AVE?

1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310 has an assessed market value of $4.4M and a total assessed value of $2M (land: $206K). Assessment data is from the NYC Department of Finance (DOF).

What is the zoning for 1265 CASTLETON AVE?

1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310 is zoned C8-1. Zoning data is from the NYC Department of City Planning (DCP). For detailed FAR, overlays, and development rights, view the full property report on RegWatch.

Who owns 1265 CASTLETON AVE?

1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310 is individually owned according to public records. Ownership data is from NYC Department of Finance assessment rolls. View the current owner of record and registered contacts in the full property report on RegWatch.

How do I get a full property report for 1265 CASTLETON AVE?

Search 1265 CASTLETON AVE on RegWatch to see its public record free — violations, permits, tax records, zoning, environmental data, and more from 250+ government sources, no credit card required. A Full Analysis report adds the complete title history, owner contacts, and a downloadable PDF.

Search Another Property

Look up violations, permits, and records for any tri-state address.

Related searches
1265 CASTLETON AVE, Staten Island, NY 10310 — Property Records, Permits, Violations, Tax & Zoning | RegWatch